IMHO it's fine, I support auto closing low quality notes in hopes that someone else would eventually notice the same issue and provide a higher quality note.  However (and again nevermind) that anonymous was the note writer and technically should get a say in this, but they wish to remain anonymous and therefore shouldn't get to have a say on this.

Yeah a new anonymous note that simply disparage the decision in a nearby note are not really helpful and should be closed, in my opinion in an ideal world anonymous notes are clear and concise.  If they can't be clear and concise on what to have changed, they should create an account and be ready to field questions.
