S-zation
I think what happened was that he moved the nodes around in version 2 of the relation and it might of gotten corrupted somehow when I reverted version 2 and version 3 (his total deletion of the relation and redrawing).  I didn't notice it when I uploaded it because I didn't receive any JOSM conflict errors.  Minus all of the dragged and shared nodes everywhere due to all of the reverts and vandalism, the geometry looks very close to the v1 when I look up the old changeset on OSMcha, so I don't think we are in that big of a mess!
and constable, I am almost completely certain that BeachBumRetiree is not him.