Jack the Ripper
Why not both?  At the intersection with Barneyville Road, Mapillary images show that north of there, it's Springhill Road, and south of there it's Springhill Church Road ("Springhill Ch Rd").  It's hard to tell in the imagery, but the south end where it meets Goodman Street says Springhill Road.  At the very north end, where it meets Wagon Wheel Road, the sign says Springhill Road.  It's worth noting that the county GIS system names the entire thing as Springhill Road.

I'll go with Springhill Road being the correct name, and Springhill Church Road being the old(?) name.