The short answer is that ground truth, verifiable by survey, is the gold standard for OSM data -- so why not go for the gold?

And the long answer... Ulster County's property records for this parcel are here:
https://ulstercountyny.gov/maps/parcel-viewer/?mapX=-8250489.506834089&mapY=5161540.1537315035&zoom=17&basemap=UCParcels&swis=512800&sbl=03800100030341900000
The housenumber is listed there as 134. But in my years of doing QA on these imported address nodes I've found many instances where the ground truth does not match the local records.

There's also the question of data license. This is government data with no explicit license declaration, so it might be considered public domain... but this sentence gives me pause: "Any sale of this map or information on this map is prohibited except by written permission of Ulster County." This isn't compatible with the ODBL that OSM uses, which permits the downstream sale of data as long as OSM is acknowledged as a source. It might be possible to get a general waiver from the county -- as far as I know it hasn't been tried. 

Anyway I hope to survey in person soon. Going for the gold!🏅