Datasets:
uid stringclasses 10
values | dataset_id stringclasses 1
value | jurisdiction stringclasses 3
values | court_level stringclasses 7
values | year int64 2.02k 2.02k | area_of_law stringclasses 10
values | pillar stringclasses 1
value | series stringclasses 1
value | input_rule_text stringclasses 10
values | input_real_world_conditions stringclasses 10
values | input_enforcement_pattern stringclasses 9
values | input_evasion_signals stringclasses 7
values | input_reform_pressure stringclasses 10
values | input_case_signals stringclasses 10
values | question stringclasses 1
value | ground_truth_label stringclasses 2
values | ground_truth_rationale stringclasses 10
values | outcome_signal stringclasses 3
values | early_window_months int64 0 12 | source_citation stringclasses 1
value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
LR-TR-001 | legal-law-real-world-coherence-decay-v0.1 | UK | High Court | 2,022 | Data Protection | systemic_legal_coherence | 4C | Rule requires explicit informed consent for tracking | Users click through complex consent banners without understanding | Enforcement inconsistent | Mass dark-pattern consent | Regulator consultation underway | Courts see rising claims | Is rule aligned with real world practice. Answer coherent or incoherent. | incoherent | Formal consent rule diverges from real user behavior and enforcement. | reform_risk | 10 | Synthetic |
LR-TR-002 | legal-law-real-world-coherence-decay-v0.1 | US | Federal | 2,019 | Securities | systemic_legal_coherence | 4C | Disclosure rules for public filings | Companies comply and markets rely on filings | Enforcement active | Low evasion | Stable regime | Courts apply consistently | Is rule aligned with real world practice. Answer coherent or incoherent. | coherent | Rule still functions as intended in practice. | stable | 0 | Synthetic |
LR-TR-003 | legal-law-real-world-coherence-decay-v0.1 | UK | Magistrates | 2,023 | Transport | systemic_legal_coherence | 4C | Law bans handheld phone use while driving | Drivers use hands-free but remain distracted | Enforcement limited | Behavior shifts but risk persists | Calls for broader law | Accident data rising | Is rule aligned with real world practice. Answer coherent or incoherent. | incoherent | Rule covers narrow behavior while risk shifts to new forms. | reform_risk | 12 | Synthetic |
LR-TR-004 | legal-law-real-world-coherence-decay-v0.1 | EU | Trial | 2,021 | Consumer | systemic_legal_coherence | 4C | Cooling-off period for distance sales | Consumers exercise right regularly | Enforcement consistent | Low evasion | Stable framework | Courts apply routinely | Is rule aligned with real world practice. Answer coherent or incoherent. | coherent | Rule still matches commercial practice. | stable | 0 | Synthetic |
LR-TR-005 | legal-law-real-world-coherence-decay-v0.1 | US | State Court | 2,020 | Cannabis | systemic_legal_coherence | 4C | State prohibition statute remains on books | Market operates openly with licenses | Selective enforcement | Widespread tolerated activity | Legislative reform pending | Courts see conflicts | Is rule aligned with real world practice. Answer coherent or incoherent. | incoherent | Statute conflicts with actual regulated practice. | doctrinal_shift_risk | 9 | Synthetic |
LR-TR-006 | legal-law-real-world-coherence-decay-v0.1 | UK | High Court | 2,018 | Contract | systemic_legal_coherence | 4C | Unfair terms protections | Businesses update terms to comply | Enforcement active | Low evasion | Stable doctrine | Courts enforce | Is rule aligned with real world practice. Answer coherent or incoherent. | coherent | Rule and market practice aligned. | stable | 0 | Synthetic |
LR-TR-007 | legal-law-real-world-coherence-decay-v0.1 | EU | Appellate | 2,022 | Employment | systemic_legal_coherence | 4C | Working time limits | Gig economy blurs employment status | Enforcement uncertain | Classification disputes rising | Policy review ongoing | Cases increasing | Is rule aligned with real world practice. Answer coherent or incoherent. | incoherent | New work models diverge from statutory assumptions. | reform_risk | 8 | Synthetic |
LR-TR-008 | legal-law-real-world-coherence-decay-v0.1 | US | Federal | 2,021 | Tax | systemic_legal_coherence | 4C | Reporting requirements for digital assets | Users underreport holdings | Enforcement expanding | High evasion signals | Regulatory updates proposed | Audit cases rising | Is rule aligned with real world practice. Answer coherent or incoherent. | incoherent | Behavior outpaces reporting regime. | reform_risk | 11 | Synthetic |
LR-TR-009 | legal-law-real-world-coherence-decay-v0.1 | UK | Court of Appeal | 2,017 | Property | systemic_legal_coherence | 4C | Land registration requirements | Transactions follow registry | Enforcement stable | Low evasion | Stable system | Courts consistent | Is rule aligned with real world practice. Answer coherent or incoherent. | coherent | Registration law still tracks practice. | stable | 0 | Synthetic |
LR-TR-010 | legal-law-real-world-coherence-decay-v0.1 | EU | Trial | 2,023 | AI Regulation | systemic_legal_coherence | 4C | Legacy liability framework | AI systems deployed widely | Enforcement unclear | Regulatory gap visible | Reform proposals active | Test cases emerging | Is rule aligned with real world practice. Answer coherent or incoherent. | incoherent | Technology outpaces liability framework. | reform_risk | 6 | Synthetic |
What this dataset is
You receive
rule text real world conditions enforcement pattern evasion signals reform pressure
You decide
Does the law still align with reality
Answer
coherent or incoherent
Why this matters
When law diverges from reality enforcement weakens reform pressure rises doctrine shifts
This dataset measures that divergence early.
- Downloads last month
- 6