relative_rank int64 0 0 | win_prob float64 0 0 | title stringlengths 32 37 | abstract stringclasses 1
value | full_text stringlengths 107 36.7k | review stringlengths 107 36.7k | source stringclasses 1
value | review_src stringlengths 37 42 | criteria_count dict | dimension_scores dict | overall_score float64 0 6 | thinking_trace stringclasses 1
value | prompt stringclasses 1
value | prompt_length int64 0 0 | conversations listlengths 2 2 | year int64 2k 2.03k |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02789-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor
and Surgical Team Workflow
Version: 2 Date: 27 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
My feedback from the review was well addressed in the responses from the authors. | Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor
and Surgical Team Workflow
Version: 2 Date: 27 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
My feedback from the review was well addressed in the responses from the authors. | BMC | 12893_2025_2789_ReviewerReport_V2_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor\nand Surgical Team Workflow\nVersion: 2 Date: 27 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\nMy feedback from the review was well addressed in the re... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02789-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor
and Surgical Team Workflow
Version: 2 Date: 06 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Ebru Önler
Reviewer's report:
Thanks for your revisions and additional files according to the reviewers' suggestions. | Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor
and Surgical Team Workflow
Version: 2 Date: 06 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Ebru Önler
Reviewer's report:
Thanks for your revisions and additional files according to the reviewers' suggestions. | BMC | 12893_2025_2789_ReviewerReport_V2_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor\nand Surgical Team Workflow\nVersion: 2 Date: 06 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Ebru Önler\nReviewer's report:\nThanks for your revisions and add... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02789-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor
and Surgical Team Workflow
Version: 2 Date: 07 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Anette Storesund
Reviewer's report:
First, I would like to express that I am happy to get the chance to review this research work.
It has been a pleasure to see a... | Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor
and Surgical Team Workflow
Version: 2 Date: 07 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Anette Storesund
Reviewer's report:
First, I would like to express that I am happy to get the chance to review this research work.
It has been a pleasure to see a... | BMC | 12893_2025_2789_ReviewerReport_V2_R6.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 7,
"importance_and_relevance": 4,
"materials_and_methods": 16,
"praise": 6,
"presentation_and_reporting": 17,
"results_and_discussion": 6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 23,
"total": 40
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.175,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.1,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4,
"praise": 0.15,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.425,
"results_and_discussion": 0.15,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.575
} | 1.975 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor\nand Surgical Team Workflow\nVersion: 2 Date: 07 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Anette Storesund\nReviewer's report:\nFirst, I would like to expr... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02789-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor
and Surgical Team Workflow
Version: 3 Date: 20 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Anette Storesund
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the very much improved manuscript. You are nearly ready to publish, but it still
needs som more adjustments. | Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor
and Surgical Team Workflow
Version: 3 Date: 20 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Anette Storesund
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the very much improved manuscript. You are nearly ready to publish, but it still
needs som more adjustments. | BMC | 12893_2025_2789_ReviewerReport_V3_R6.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 0.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor\nand Surgical Team Workflow\nVersion: 3 Date: 20 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Anette Storesund\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for the very much... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02789-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor
and Surgical Team Workflow
Version: 4 Date: 09 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Anette Storesund
Reviewer's report:
I will congratulate the authors on finishing a good manuscript. I have only a final comment:
Please make sure that the Supplem... | Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor
and Surgical Team Workflow
Version: 4 Date: 09 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Anette Storesund
Reviewer's report:
I will congratulate the authors on finishing a good manuscript. I have only a final comment:
Please make sure that the Supplem... | BMC | 12893_2025_2789_ReviewerReport_V4_R6.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.6666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.6666666666666666
} | 1.666667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Surgical Time-Out: The Relationship Between Perceptions of a Safety-task Anchor\nand Surgical Team Workflow\nVersion: 4 Date: 09 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Anette Storesund\nReviewer's report:\nI will congratulate the aut... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02752-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 3 Date: 24 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
This paper has a novel idea. Through the pre-planning of artificial intelligence, the difficulty
of total hip revision surg... | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 3 Date: 24 Jun 2024
Reviewer's report:
This paper has a novel idea. Through the pre-planning of artificial intelligence, the difficulty
of total hip revision surg... | BMC | 12893_2024_2752_ReviewerReport_V3_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.6666666666666666,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333,
"praise": 0.6666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.3333333333333333
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision\nsurgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty\nVersion: 3 Date: 24 Jun 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis paper has a novel id... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02752-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 3 Date: 24 Jun 2024
Reviewer: Ryohei Takada
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript was well-written and included interesting topic. AIhip will get improved if the
sy... | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 3 Date: 24 Jun 2024
Reviewer: Ryohei Takada
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript was well-written and included interesting topic. AIhip will get improved if the
sy... | BMC | 12893_2024_2752_ReviewerReport_V3_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.5,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 2.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision\nsurgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty\nVersion: 3 Date: 24 Jun 2024\nReviewer: Ryohei Takada\nReviewer's report:\... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02752-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 3 Date: 03 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
Although this is considered an interesting and innovative study, I believe that including the
time intervals between the in... | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 3 Date: 03 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
Although this is considered an interesting and innovative study, I believe that including the
time intervals between the in... | BMC | 12893_2024_2752_ReviewerReport_V3_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 6,
"total": 6
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.16666666666666666,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.5,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6666666666666666,
"praise": 0.16666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333,
"results_and_discussion": 0.5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 3.333333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision\nsurgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty\nVersion: 3 Date: 03 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\nAlthough this is consider... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02752-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 4 Date: 10 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The revisions made to the study have been appropriately completed. The study can be accepted. | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 4 Date: 10 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The revisions made to the study have been appropriately completed. The study can be accepted. | BMC | 12893_2024_2752_ReviewerReport_V4_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision\nsurgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty\nVersion: 4 Date: 10 Sep 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe revisions made to the... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02752-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 4 Date: 22 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Won Yong Shon
Reviewer's report:
Overall, this is an innovative study focusing on the efficiency of artificial intelligence in
pla... | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 4 Date: 22 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Won Yong Shon
Reviewer's report:
Overall, this is an innovative study focusing on the efficiency of artificial intelligence in
pla... | BMC | 12893_2024_2752_ReviewerReport_V4_R9.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 10
} | {
"criticism": 0.1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6,
"praise": 0.2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.3
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision\nsurgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty\nVersion: 4 Date: 22 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Won Yong Shon\nReviewer's report:\... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02752-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 4 Date: 22 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear Author,
I am writing in reference to your manuscript entitled "Efficacy of an Artificial Intelligence
Preoperative Pla... | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 4 Date: 22 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Dear Author,
I am writing in reference to your manuscript entitled "Efficacy of an Artificial Intelligence
Preoperative Pla... | BMC | 12893_2024_2752_ReviewerReport_V4_R8.pdf | {
"criticism": 8,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 4,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 18
} | {
"criticism": 0.4444444444444444,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2777777777777778,
"praise": 0.05555555555555555,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.16666666666666666,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2222222222222222,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.16666666666666666
} | 1.333333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision\nsurgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty\nVersion: 4 Date: 22 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nDear Author,\nI am writin... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02752-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 4 Date: 23 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Nicolò Fabbri
Reviewer's report:
Dear Author,
thank you for your responses; no further revisions are necessary. | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 4 Date: 23 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Nicolò Fabbri
Reviewer's report:
Dear Author,
thank you for your responses; no further revisions are necessary. | BMC | 12893_2024_2752_ReviewerReport_V4_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision\nsurgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty\nVersion: 4 Date: 23 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Nicolò Fabbri\nReviewer's report:\... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02752-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 4 Date: 24 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
I appreciate the work you submitted.
Some suggestions:
If AI was the major variable being studied, I would suggest looking ... | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 4 Date: 24 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
I appreciate the work you submitted.
Some suggestions:
If AI was the major variable being studied, I would suggest looking ... | BMC | 12893_2024_2752_ReviewerReport_V4_R6.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 3,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 4
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.75,
"praise": 0.25,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision\nsurgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty\nVersion: 4 Date: 24 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nI appreciate the work you... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02752-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 5 Date: 15 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
interesting study
discussion is pretty poor
maybe a wider approach in the discussion section on AI should be faced
consider... | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 5 Date: 15 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
interesting study
discussion is pretty poor
maybe a wider approach in the discussion section on AI should be faced
consider... | BMC | 12893_2024_2752_ReviewerReport_V5_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision\nsurgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty\nVersion: 5 Date: 15 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\ninteresting study\ndiscus... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02752-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 5 Date: 18 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for allowing me the opportunity to review the article.
I appreciate that the author took the time and individuall... | Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision
surgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty
Version: 5 Date: 18 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for allowing me the opportunity to review the article.
I appreciate that the author took the time and individuall... | BMC | 12893_2024_2752_ReviewerReport_V5_R6.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0.2857142857142857,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2857142857142857,
"materials_and_methods": 0.14285714285714285,
"praise": 0.14285714285714285,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2857142857142857,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.14285714285714285
} | 1.285714 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Efficacy of an artificial intelligence preoperative planning system for assisting in revision\nsurgery after artificial total hip arthroplasty\nVersion: 5 Date: 18 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for allowing me... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02792-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 1 Date: 04 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Julien Epailly
Reviewer's report: | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 1 Date: 04 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Julien Epailly
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12893_2025_2792_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic\nScoping Review\nVersion: 1 Date: 04 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Julien Epailly\nReviewer's report:",
"role": "assistant"
}
] | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02792-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 1 Date: 15 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The impact of patient death on surgeons is worthy to discuss. The content to discussion is
changing in accordance with times.
This article is well written.
I found so... | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 1 Date: 15 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The impact of patient death on surgeons is worthy to discuss. The content to discussion is
changing in accordance with times.
This article is well written.
I found so... | BMC | 12893_2025_2792_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 5
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2,
"praise": 0.4,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4,
"results_and_discussion": 0.4,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.6
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic\nScoping Review\nVersion: 1 Date: 15 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe impact of patient death on surgeons is worthy to discuss. The co... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02792-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 1 Date: 19 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Hisayoshi Kawahara
Reviewer's report:
Seven Singapore possibly physicians addressed a question “what is known of the effects
of caring for the dying and the impact of patient... | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 1 Date: 19 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Hisayoshi Kawahara
Reviewer's report:
Seven Singapore possibly physicians addressed a question “what is known of the effects
of caring for the dying and the impact of patient... | BMC | 12893_2025_2792_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 4,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 20
} | {
"criticism": 0.2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.1,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.15,
"results_and_discussion": 0.15,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.1
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic\nScoping Review\nVersion: 1 Date: 19 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Hisayoshi Kawahara\nReviewer's report:\nSeven Singapore possibly physicians a... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02792-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 1 Date: 21 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Julien Hasselmann
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript has the potential to make a meaningful contribution to the literature on surgeon
well-being and professional identity.
BA... | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 1 Date: 21 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Julien Hasselmann
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript has the potential to make a meaningful contribution to the literature on surgeon
well-being and professional identity.
BA... | BMC | 12893_2025_2792_ReviewerReport_V1_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 3,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 7,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 5,
"results_and_discussion": 4,
"suggestion_and_solution": 6,
"total": 17
} | {
"criticism": 0.17647058823529413,
"example": 0.17647058823529413,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.11764705882352941,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4117647058823529,
"praise": 0.058823529411764705,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.29411764705882354,
"results_and_discussion": 0.23529411764705882,
"suggestion_... | 1.823529 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic\nScoping Review\nVersion: 1 Date: 21 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Julien Hasselmann\nReviewer's report:\nThis manuscript has the potential to m... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02792-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 4 Date: 06 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I would like to express my appreciation for your innovative endeavor in conducting an AI-
assisted scoping review examining the effects of caring for dying patients a... | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 4 Date: 06 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I would like to express my appreciation for your innovative endeavor in conducting an AI-
assisted scoping review examining the effects of caring for dying patients a... | BMC | 12893_2025_2792_ReviewerReport_V4_R8.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 5,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 10,
"total": 12
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.08333333333333333,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.4166666666666667,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.16666666666666666,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.8333333333333334
} | 2.333333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic\nScoping Review\nVersion: 4 Date: 06 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nI would like to express my appreciation for your innovative endeavor... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02792-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 4 Date: 06 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Sarra Saad
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors,
I would like to extend my congratulations on the high quality of the scientific data presented in
your article. It constitutes a h... | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 4 Date: 06 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Sarra Saad
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors,
I would like to extend my congratulations on the high quality of the scientific data presented in
your article. It constitutes a h... | BMC | 12893_2025_2792_ReviewerReport_V4_R7.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 4,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.14285714285714285,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2857142857142857,
"praise": 0.2857142857142857,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2857142857142857,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5714285714285714
} | 1.571429 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic\nScoping Review\nVersion: 4 Date: 06 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Sarra Saad\nReviewer's report:\nDear authors,\nI would like to extend my cong... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02792-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 4 Date: 07 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Vincenzo Lizzi
Reviewer's report:
First of all, thank you so much for involving me in the review of this manuscript.
Very interesting and original topic that is always talked... | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 4 Date: 07 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Vincenzo Lizzi
Reviewer's report:
First of all, thank you so much for involving me in the review of this manuscript.
Very interesting and original topic that is always talked... | BMC | 12893_2025_2792_ReviewerReport_V4_R9.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.14285714285714285,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.7142857142857143,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5714285714285714,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2857142857142857,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.14285714285714285
} | 1.857143 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic\nScoping Review\nVersion: 4 Date: 07 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Vincenzo Lizzi\nReviewer's report:\nFirst of all, thank you so much for invol... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02792-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 5 Date: 13 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I would like to commend the authors for their thoughtful revisions. The manuscript now
demonstrates enhanced clarity, methodological rigor, and depth, particularly in... | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 5 Date: 13 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I would like to commend the authors for their thoughtful revisions. The manuscript now
demonstrates enhanced clarity, methodological rigor, and depth, particularly in... | BMC | 12893_2025_2792_ReviewerReport_V5_R8.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.3333333333333333,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.3333333333333333
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic\nScoping Review\nVersion: 5 Date: 13 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nI would like to commend the authors for their thoughtful revisions. ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02792-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 5 Date: 15 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Vincenzo Lizzi
Reviewer's report:
I read the article again and the changes I suggested were made. For me the article can be accepted. | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 5 Date: 15 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Vincenzo Lizzi
Reviewer's report:
I read the article again and the changes I suggested were made. For me the article can be accepted. | BMC | 12893_2025_2792_ReviewerReport_V5_R9.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic\nScoping Review\nVersion: 5 Date: 15 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Vincenzo Lizzi\nReviewer's report:\nI read the article again and the changes ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02792-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 5 Date: 19 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I appreciate authors effort to organize and summarize various aspects about the impact of death
and dying on surgeons using the modern AI tool. This paper is worthy ... | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 5 Date: 19 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I appreciate authors effort to organize and summarize various aspects about the impact of death
and dying on surgeons using the modern AI tool. This paper is worthy ... | BMC | 12893_2025_2792_ReviewerReport_V5_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic\nScoping Review\nVersion: 5 Date: 19 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nI appreciate authors effort to organize and summarize various aspect... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02792-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 5 Date: 22 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I can appreciate your inquiry regarding this subject. I appreciate the opportunity to review the
manuscript and enjoyed reading it. I have provided general comments r... | Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic
Scoping Review
Version: 5 Date: 22 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I can appreciate your inquiry regarding this subject. I appreciate the opportunity to review the
manuscript and enjoyed reading it. I have provided general comments r... | BMC | 12893_2025_2792_ReviewerReport_V5_R10.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 4
} | {
"criticism": 0.25,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0.75 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The Impact of Death and Caring for the Dying on Surgeons- An AI assisted Systematic\nScoping Review\nVersion: 5 Date: 22 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nI can appreciate your inquiry regarding this subject. I appreciate t... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02754-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review
Version: 2 Date: 03 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Excellent review of KAT | Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review
Version: 2 Date: 03 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Excellent review of KAT | BMC | 12893_2024_2754_ReviewerReport_V2_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review\nVersion: 2 Date: 03 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nExcellent review of KAT",
"role": "assistant"
}
] | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02754-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review
Version: 2 Date: 10 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Abhinav Seth
Reviewer's report:
This is an excellent and well-written review on kidney autotransplantation. I would greatly
appreciate it if you could incorporate the following additional information into the manuscr... | Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review
Version: 2 Date: 10 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Abhinav Seth
Reviewer's report:
This is an excellent and well-written review on kidney autotransplantation. I would greatly
appreciate it if you could incorporate the following additional information into the manuscr... | BMC | 12893_2024_2754_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 10
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2,
"praise": 0.1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2
} | 0.6 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review\nVersion: 2 Date: 10 Nov 2024\nReviewer: Abhinav Seth\nReviewer's report:\nThis is an excellent and well-written review on kidney autotransplantation. I would gr... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02754-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review
Version: 3 Date: 04 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Done at time of initial review | Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review
Version: 3 Date: 04 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Done at time of initial review | BMC | 12893_2024_2754_ReviewerReport_V3_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review\nVersion: 3 Date: 04 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nDone at time of initial review",
"role": "assistant"
}
] | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02754-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review
Version: 3 Date: 12 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The purpose of this study was to review kidney autotransplantation and provide consolidated
updates on clinical advance in the practice. Overall, the authors accomplished their intent well
and thoroughly. Fo... | Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review
Version: 3 Date: 12 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The purpose of this study was to review kidney autotransplantation and provide consolidated
updates on clinical advance in the practice. Overall, the authors accomplished their intent well
and thoroughly. Fo... | BMC | 12893_2024_2754_ReviewerReport_V3_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 5
} | {
"criticism": 0.2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.6,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2
} | 1.4 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review\nVersion: 3 Date: 12 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe purpose of this study was to review kidney autotransplantation and provide consolidated\nupdates on clinica... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02754-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review
Version: 3 Date: 16 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Richard E. Link
Reviewer's report:
This is a very well written and thorough review article about kidney autotransplantation. It
provides a lot of very clinically relevant information to the reader and is well worthy ... | Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review
Version: 3 Date: 16 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Richard E. Link
Reviewer's report:
This is a very well written and thorough review article about kidney autotransplantation. It
provides a lot of very clinically relevant information to the reader and is well worthy ... | BMC | 12893_2024_2754_ReviewerReport_V3_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 4,
"materials_and_methods": 10,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 19
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.05263157894736842,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.21052631578947367,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5263157894736842,
"praise": 0.10526315789473684,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.05263157894736842,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2631578947368421
} | 1.210526 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Clinical advances in kidney autotransplantation:a review\nVersion: 3 Date: 16 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Richard E. Link\nReviewer's report:\nThis is a very well written and thorough review article about kidney autotransplant... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 0 Date: 21 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Yossef Ezra
Reviewer's report:
Figure 6 may be confusing for most readers and could be om... | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 0 Date: 21 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Yossef Ezra
Reviewer's report:
Figure 6 may be confusing for most readers and could be om... | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V0_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 4 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 0 Date: 21 Sep 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 0 Date: 26 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Sanjoy Kumar Bhattacharyya
Reviewer's report: | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 0 Date: 26 Sep 2024
Reviewer: Sanjoy Kumar Bhattacharyya
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V0_R6.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 0 Date: 26 Sep 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 0 Date: 02 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
I read with great interest the Manuscript titled “Sonographic and surgical outcom... | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 0 Date: 02 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
I read with great interest the Manuscript titled “Sonographic and surgical outcom... | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 8
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.25,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.375,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5,
"results_and_discussion": 0.625,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.625
} | 2.875 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 0 Date: 02 Oct 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 0 Date: 03 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review this article on an interesting closure te... | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 0 Date: 03 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to review this article on an interesting closure te... | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V0_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 11,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 6,
"results_and_discussion": 7,
"suggestion_and_solution": 12,
"total": 26
} | {
"criticism": 0.038461538461538464,
"example": 0.038461538461538464,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.07692307692307693,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4230769230769231,
"praise": 0.07692307692307693,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.23076923076923078,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2692307692307692,
"suggestion_... | 1.615385 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 0 Date: 03 Oct 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 1 Date: 09 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Yossef Ezra
Reviewer's report:
No comments. | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 1 Date: 09 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Yossef Ezra
Reviewer's report:
No comments. | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V1_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 1 Date: 09 Oct 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 1 Date: 15 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Sanjoy Kumar Bhattacharyya
Reviewer's report: | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 1 Date: 15 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Sanjoy Kumar Bhattacharyya
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V1_R6.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 1 Date: 15 Oct 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 1 Date: 16 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Panagiotis Peitsidis
Reviewer's report:
This is an excellent systematic review and metan... | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 1 Date: 16 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Panagiotis Peitsidis
Reviewer's report:
This is an excellent systematic review and metan... | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V1_R7.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 4
} | {
"criticism": 0.25,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.75,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.25,
"results_and_discussion": 0.25,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 2.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 1 Date: 16 Oct 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 1 Date: 18 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
Prior concerns are adequately addressed and the manuscript can be published | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 1 Date: 18 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
Prior concerns are adequately addressed and the manuscript can be published | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 1 Date: 18 Oct 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 1 Date: 19 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
I read with great interest the Manuscript titled “Sonographic outcomes and surgic... | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 1 Date: 19 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
I read with great interest the Manuscript titled “Sonographic outcomes and surgic... | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 3,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 5
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6,
"praise": 0.6,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4,
"results_and_discussion": 0.6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.4
} | 2.8 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 1 Date: 19 Oct 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 2 Date: 30 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Panagiotis Peitsidis
Reviewer's report:
The article has been revised according to the rev... | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 2 Date: 30 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Panagiotis Peitsidis
Reviewer's report:
The article has been revised according to the rev... | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V2_R7.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 2 Date: 30 Oct 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 2 Date: 30 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Sanjoy Kumar Bhattacharyya
Reviewer's report: | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 2 Date: 30 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Sanjoy Kumar Bhattacharyya
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V2_R6.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 2 Date: 30 Oct 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 2 Date: 04 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
General: a systematic review and meta-analyses of RCTs analyzing the effects of P... | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 2 Date: 04 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
General: a systematic review and meta-analyses of RCTs analyzing the effects of P... | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V2_R10.pdf | {
"criticism": 11,
"example": 13,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 19,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 15,
"results_and_discussion": 4,
"suggestion_and_solution": 13,
"total": 37
} | {
"criticism": 0.2972972972972973,
"example": 0.35135135135135137,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.05405405405405406,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5135135135135135,
"praise": 0.02702702702702703,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.40540540540540543,
"results_and_discussion": 0.10810810810810811,
"suggestion_an... | 2.108108 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 2 Date: 04 Nov 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 3 Date: 25 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Dazhi Fan
Reviewer's report:
Thanks for your invitation to review.
The authors aimed to a... | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 3 Date: 25 Nov 2024
Reviewer: Dazhi Fan
Reviewer's report:
Thanks for your invitation to review.
The authors aimed to a... | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V3_R13.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 7
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.14285714285714285,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2857142857142857,
"praise": 0.2857142857142857,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2857142857142857,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.14285714285714285
} | 1.142857 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 3 Date: 25 Nov 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 3 Date: 01 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Marco la Verde
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript covers an important clinically relevant... | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 3 Date: 01 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Marco la Verde
Reviewer's report:
This manuscript covers an important clinically relevant... | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V3_R16.pdf | {
"criticism": 6,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 16,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 11,
"results_and_discussion": 9,
"suggestion_and_solution": 18,
"total": 31
} | {
"criticism": 0.1935483870967742,
"example": 0.06451612903225806,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.06451612903225806,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5161290322580645,
"praise": 0.0967741935483871,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3548387096774194,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2903225806451613,
"suggestion_and_s... | 2.16129 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 3 Date: 01 Dec 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 4 Date: 26 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Dazhi Fan
Reviewer's report:
Congratulations. | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 4 Date: 26 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Dazhi Fan
Reviewer's report:
Congratulations. | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V4_R13.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 4 Date: 26 Dec 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 4 Date: 27 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors, please address the following poi... | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 4 Date: 27 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors, please address the following poi... | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V4_R19.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 3,
"materials_and_methods": 10,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 10,
"suggestion_and_solution": 10,
"total": 14
} | {
"criticism": 0.14285714285714285,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.21428571428571427,
"materials_and_methods": 0.7142857142857143,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.21428571428571427,
"results_and_discussion": 0.7142857142857143,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.7142857142857143
} | 2.714286 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 4 Date: 27 Dec 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02796-x | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 5 Date: 24 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
The responses are satisfactory | Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine
closure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized
trials
Version: 5 Date: 24 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
The responses are satisfactory | BMC | 12893_2025_2796_ReviewerReport_V5_R19.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Ultrasound outcomes and surgical parameters of the double-layer purse-string uterine\nclosure technique in cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized\ntrials\nVersion: 5 Date: 24 Jan 2025\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02768-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 1 Date: 14 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is a retrospective comparative study between pure transanal endorectal pull-... | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 1 Date: 14 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is a retrospective comparative study between pure transanal endorectal pull-... | BMC | 12893_2025_2768_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 4,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 9
} | {
"criticism": 0.4444444444444444,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2222222222222222,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5555555555555556,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.1111111111111111,
"results_and_discussion": 0.6666666666666666,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2222222222222222
} | 2.222222 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-\nthrough in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective\nstudy\nVersion: 1 Date: 14 Jul 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02768-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 1 Date: 20 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal p... | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 1 Date: 20 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal p... | BMC | 12893_2025_2768_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 5,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 13,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 7,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 8,
"total": 26
} | {
"criticism": 0.19230769230769232,
"example": 0.07692307692307693,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.07692307692307693,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2692307692307692,
"results_and_discussion": 0.11538461538461539,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.3076923076923077
} | 1.538462 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-\nthrough in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective\nstudy\nVersion: 1 Date: 20 Jul 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02768-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 1 Date: 01 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
This paper is a retrospective study comparing the two surgical techniques.
In con... | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 1 Date: 01 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
This paper is a retrospective study comparing the two surgical techniques.
In con... | BMC | 12893_2025_2768_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 6
} | {
"criticism": 0.16666666666666666,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.8333333333333334,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.16666666666666666,
"results_and_discussion": 0.5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.16666666666666666
} | 1.833333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-\nthrough in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective\nstudy\nVersion: 1 Date: 01 Aug 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02768-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 2 Date: 21 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
Authors responded properly all questions.
I do not have more comments.
Thanks | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 2 Date: 21 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
Authors responded properly all questions.
I do not have more comments.
Thanks | BMC | 12893_2025_2768_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0.3333333333333333,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0.333333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-\nthrough in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective\nstudy\nVersion: 2 Date: 21 Aug 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02768-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 2 Date: 02 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript is still suffering from major methodological and presentation issu... | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 2 Date: 02 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript is still suffering from major methodological and presentation issu... | BMC | 12893_2025_2768_ReviewerReport_V2_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 6,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 9
} | {
"criticism": 0.6666666666666666,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5555555555555556,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3333333333333333,
"results_and_discussion": 0.5555555555555556,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.1111111111111111
} | 2.222222 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-\nthrough in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective\nstudy\nVersion: 2 Date: 02 Sep 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02768-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 2 Date: 10 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
Revisions and additions have been made in accordance with reviewer comments.
Some... | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 2 Date: 10 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
Revisions and additions have been made in accordance with reviewer comments.
Some... | BMC | 12893_2025_2768_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0.5,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-\nthrough in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective\nstudy\nVersion: 2 Date: 10 Sep 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02768-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 3 Date: 05 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
There are still several important issues with this manuscript.
Abstract
Results &... | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 3 Date: 05 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
There are still several important issues with this manuscript.
Abstract
Results &... | BMC | 12893_2025_2768_ReviewerReport_V3_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 11,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 7,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 8,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 16
} | {
"criticism": 0.6875,
"example": 0.125,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4375,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.25,
"results_and_discussion": 0.5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.1875
} | 2.1875 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-\nthrough in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective\nstudy\nVersion: 3 Date: 05 Oct 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02768-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 3 Date: 10 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
It has been revised and edited according to the reviewer's comments.
However, the... | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 3 Date: 10 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
It has been revised and edited according to the reviewer's comments.
However, the... | BMC | 12893_2025_2768_ReviewerReport_V3_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 5
} | {
"criticism": 0.2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.4,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.4
} | 1.4 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-\nthrough in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective\nstudy\nVersion: 3 Date: 10 Oct 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02768-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 4 Date: 26 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thanks for the reply regarding the question.
If the extent of the aganglionic les... | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 4 Date: 26 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thanks for the reply regarding the question.
If the extent of the aganglionic les... | BMC | 12893_2025_2768_ReviewerReport_V4_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0.5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-\nthrough in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective\nstudy\nVersion: 4 Date: 26 Nov 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02768-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 4 Date: 30 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed several of the major issues pointed out and the manusc... | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 4 Date: 30 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors have addressed several of the major issues pointed out and the manusc... | BMC | 12893_2025_2768_ReviewerReport_V4_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 9,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 6,
"total": 10
} | {
"criticism": 0.1,
"example": 0.2,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.1,
"praise": 0.1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.9,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.6
} | 2.2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-\nthrough in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective\nstudy\nVersion: 4 Date: 30 Nov 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02768-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 5 Date: 30 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
I have confirmed the corrections. Congratulations. | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 5 Date: 30 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
I have confirmed the corrections. Congratulations. | BMC | 12893_2025_2768_ReviewerReport_V5_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-\nthrough in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective\nstudy\nVersion: 5 Date: 30 Dec 2024\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02768-1 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 5 Date: 08 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors have now mostly addressed the Reviewers' comments. The manuscript nee... | Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-
through in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective
study
Version: 5 Date: 08 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors have now mostly addressed the Reviewers' comments. The manuscript nee... | BMC | 12893_2025_2768_ReviewerReport_V5_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: One stage transanal versus one stage laparoscopic-assisted transanal endorectal pull-\nthrough in the management of Hirschsprung’s Disease in pediatric age group; A retrospective\nstudy\nVersion: 5 Date: 08 Jan 2025\nRe... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02708-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The prognostic value of the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) and platelet-to-
lymphocyte ratio (PLR) in colorectal cancer and colorectal anastomotic leakage patients#a
retrospective study
Version: 3 Date: 27 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
Xu N et al. investigated the prognostic significance of neutrophil-to-lym... | Title: The prognostic value of the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) and platelet-to-
lymphocyte ratio (PLR) in colorectal cancer and colorectal anastomotic leakage patients#a
retrospective study
Version: 3 Date: 27 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
Xu N et al. investigated the prognostic significance of neutrophil-to-lym... | BMC | 12893_2024_2708_ReviewerReport_V3_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 4,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 3,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 11
} | {
"criticism": 0.09090909090909091,
"example": 0.36363636363636365,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.09090909090909091,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2727272727272727,
"praise": 0.09090909090909091,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.18181818181818182,
"results_and_discussion": 0.09090909090909091,
"suggestion_a... | 1.272727 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The prognostic value of the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) and platelet-to-\nlymphocyte ratio (PLR) in colorectal cancer and colorectal anastomotic leakage patients#a\nretrospective study\nVersion: 3 Date: 27 Aug ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02708-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The prognostic value of the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) and platelet-to-
lymphocyte ratio (PLR) in colorectal cancer and colorectal anastomotic leakage patients#a
retrospective study
Version: 3 Date: 14 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is an interesting and well-designed study. The authors postulated li... | Title: The prognostic value of the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) and platelet-to-
lymphocyte ratio (PLR) in colorectal cancer and colorectal anastomotic leakage patients#a
retrospective study
Version: 3 Date: 14 Sep 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is an interesting and well-designed study. The authors postulated li... | BMC | 12893_2024_2708_ReviewerReport_V3_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 2,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 12,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 6,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 8,
"total": 19
} | {
"criticism": 0.05263157894736842,
"example": 0.10526315789473684,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.10526315789473684,
"materials_and_methods": 0.631578947368421,
"praise": 0.05263157894736842,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3157894736842105,
"results_and_discussion": 0.05263157894736842,
"suggestion_and... | 1.736842 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The prognostic value of the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) and platelet-to-\nlymphocyte ratio (PLR) in colorectal cancer and colorectal anastomotic leakage patients#a\nretrospective study\nVersion: 3 Date: 14 Sep ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02708-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The prognostic value of the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) and platelet-to-
lymphocyte ratio (PLR) in colorectal cancer and colorectal anastomotic leakage patients#a
retrospective study
Version: 4 Date: 16 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
The current version of the manuscript is acceptable. Congratulation to ... | Title: The prognostic value of the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) and platelet-to-
lymphocyte ratio (PLR) in colorectal cancer and colorectal anastomotic leakage patients#a
retrospective study
Version: 4 Date: 16 Oct 2024
Reviewer's report:
The current version of the manuscript is acceptable. Congratulation to ... | BMC | 12893_2024_2708_ReviewerReport_V4_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.5,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The prognostic value of the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) and platelet-to-\nlymphocyte ratio (PLR) in colorectal cancer and colorectal anastomotic leakage patients#a\nretrospective study\nVersion: 4 Date: 16 Oct ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02708-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: The prognostic value of the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) and platelet-to-
lymphocyte ratio (PLR) in colorectal cancer and colorectal anastomotic leakage patients#a
retrospective study
Version: 4 Date: 22 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Xu N et al. should be commended to investigate the prognostic value of th... | Title: The prognostic value of the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) and platelet-to-
lymphocyte ratio (PLR) in colorectal cancer and colorectal anastomotic leakage patients#a
retrospective study
Version: 4 Date: 22 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
Xu N et al. should be commended to investigate the prognostic value of th... | BMC | 12893_2024_2708_ReviewerReport_V4_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 3,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 10
} | {
"criticism": 0.1,
"example": 0.3,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.1,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4,
"praise": 0.1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.1,
"results_and_discussion": 0.1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2
} | 1.4 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: The prognostic value of the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR) and platelet-to-\nlymphocyte ratio (PLR) in colorectal cancer and colorectal anastomotic leakage patients#a\nretrospective study\nVersion: 4 Date: 22 Nov ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02787-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Pancreatic exocrine insufficiency after pancreatic resection: a systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 04 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Wendy Muircroft
Reviewer's report:
Many thanks for the opportunity to review this quality review paper.
The topic is relevant to the care of patients who frequently experience long-term seque... | Title: Pancreatic exocrine insufficiency after pancreatic resection: a systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 04 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Wendy Muircroft
Reviewer's report:
Many thanks for the opportunity to review this quality review paper.
The topic is relevant to the care of patients who frequently experience long-term seque... | BMC | 12893_2025_2787_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 3,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 8,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 5,
"results_and_discussion": 5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 6,
"total": 18
} | {
"criticism": 0.16666666666666666,
"example": 0.16666666666666666,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.1111111111111111,
"materials_and_methods": 0.4444444444444444,
"praise": 0.1111111111111111,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2777777777777778,
"results_and_discussion": 0.2777777777777778,
"suggestion_and_s... | 1.888889 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Pancreatic exocrine insufficiency after pancreatic resection: a systematic review\nVersion: 1 Date: 04 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Wendy Muircroft\nReviewer's report:\nMany thanks for the opportunity to review this quality rev... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02787-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Pancreatic exocrine insufficiency after pancreatic resection: a systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
as per report | Title: Pancreatic exocrine insufficiency after pancreatic resection: a systematic review
Version: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
as per report | BMC | 12893_2025_2787_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Pancreatic exocrine insufficiency after pancreatic resection: a systematic review\nVersion: 1 Date: 11 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nas per report",
"role": "assistant"
}
] | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02787-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Pancreatic exocrine insufficiency after pancreatic resection: a systematic review
Version: 2 Date: 01 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I am happy that my comments have been adequately addressed.
I have made some minor corrections to the latest track changes by the authors. | Title: Pancreatic exocrine insufficiency after pancreatic resection: a systematic review
Version: 2 Date: 01 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I am happy that my comments have been adequately addressed.
I have made some minor corrections to the latest track changes by the authors. | BMC | 12893_2025_2787_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Pancreatic exocrine insufficiency after pancreatic resection: a systematic review\nVersion: 2 Date: 01 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nI am happy that my comments have been adequately addressed.\nI have made some minor co... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02779-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 1 Date: 17 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Ioannis Stavrakakis
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors
This is overall a nicely written narrative review of the literature which tends to summarize... | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 1 Date: 17 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Ioannis Stavrakakis
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors
This is overall a nicely written narrative review of the literature which tends to summarize... | BMC | 12893_2025_2779_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 5,
"example": 15,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 13,
"praise": 7,
"presentation_and_reporting": 20,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 31,
"total": 52
} | {
"criticism": 0.09615384615384616,
"example": 0.28846153846153844,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.25,
"praise": 0.1346153846153846,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.38461538461538464,
"results_and_discussion": 0.038461538461538464,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5961538461538461... | 1.788462 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined\nwith Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries\nVersion: 1 Date: 17 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Ioannis Stavrakakis\nReviewer's report:\nDear a... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02779-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 1 Date: 19 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
First of all, congratulation on a well-written paper. It deals with frequent topic among
orthopaedic surgeons, and frequent injury that... | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 1 Date: 19 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
First of all, congratulation on a well-written paper. It deals with frequent topic among
orthopaedic surgeons, and frequent injury that... | BMC | 12893_2025_2779_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 2,
"total": 5
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.2,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2,
"praise": 0.2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.2,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.4
} | 1.2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined\nwith Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries\nVersion: 1 Date: 19 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nFirst of all, congratulation on a wel... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02779-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 1 Date: 22 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Aleksandar Leši#
Reviewer's report:
to be illustrative this article need illustrations | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 1 Date: 22 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Aleksandar Leši#
Reviewer's report:
to be illustrative this article need illustrations | BMC | 12893_2025_2779_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined\nwith Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries\nVersion: 1 Date: 22 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Aleksandar Leši#\nReviewer's report:\nto be il... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02779-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 1 Date: 27 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is a nattative review on syndesmotic injuries and deltoid injuries.
The authors have covered a wide spectrum of these pathologies a... | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 1 Date: 27 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is a nattative review on syndesmotic injuries and deltoid injuries.
The authors have covered a wide spectrum of these pathologies a... | BMC | 12893_2025_2779_ReviewerReport_V1_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.5,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined\nwith Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries\nVersion: 1 Date: 27 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis is a nattative review on syndesmo... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02779-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 2 Date: 03 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Ioannis Stavrakakis
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors
Thanks a lot for revising the manuscript.
I think that the current version of your paper is ... | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 2 Date: 03 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Ioannis Stavrakakis
Reviewer's report:
Dear authors
Thanks a lot for revising the manuscript.
I think that the current version of your paper is ... | BMC | 12893_2025_2779_ReviewerReport_V2_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 4
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.25,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.75,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined\nwith Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries\nVersion: 2 Date: 03 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Ioannis Stavrakakis\nReviewer's report:\nDear a... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02779-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 2 Date: 08 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Aleksandar Leši#
Reviewer's report:
none | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 2 Date: 08 Jan 2025
Reviewer: Aleksandar Leši#
Reviewer's report:
none | BMC | 12893_2025_2779_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined\nwith Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries\nVersion: 2 Date: 08 Jan 2025\nReviewer: Aleksandar Leši#\nReviewer's report:\nnone",
... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02779-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 2 Date: 09 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Considering the topic, types of treatmen of this injury, and many papers about this topic, this
paper - review should serve to young pr... | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 2 Date: 09 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
Considering the topic, types of treatmen of this injury, and many papers about this topic, this
paper - review should serve to young pr... | BMC | 12893_2025_2779_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined\nwith Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries\nVersion: 2 Date: 09 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nConsidering the topic, types of treatm... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02779-y | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 2 Date: 10 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I have read the corrections of the authors in all the comments of all the reviewers and they have
significantly improved the paper
Maybe... | Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined
with Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries
Version: 2 Date: 10 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
I have read the corrections of the authors in all the comments of all the reviewers and they have
significantly improved the paper
Maybe... | BMC | 12893_2025_2779_ReviewerReport_V2_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Advancements in Minimally Invasive Treatment of Deltoid Ligament Injuries Combined\nwith Distal Tibiofibular Syndesmosis Injuries\nVersion: 2 Date: 10 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nI have read the corrections of the aut... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02780-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control
Study
Version: 0 Date: 03 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The reasons for tolerance in allogeneic transplantation are not solely due to factors such as
MELD score, indication for liver transplantation (LT), acute cellular rejection (A... | Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control
Study
Version: 0 Date: 03 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The reasons for tolerance in allogeneic transplantation are not solely due to factors such as
MELD score, indication for liver transplantation (LT), acute cellular rejection (A... | BMC | 12893_2025_2780_ReviewerReport_V0_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control\nStudy\nVersion: 0 Date: 03 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe reasons for tolerance in allogeneic transplantation are not solely due to ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02780-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control
Study
Version: 0 Date: 09 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript is updated and readable, and the authors have well reported and analyzed a single
center experience to investigate the incidence and potential predictors of immu... | Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control
Study
Version: 0 Date: 09 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript is updated and readable, and the authors have well reported and analyzed a single
center experience to investigate the incidence and potential predictors of immu... | BMC | 12893_2025_2780_ReviewerReport_V0_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 11,
"praise": 4,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 6,
"total": 17
} | {
"criticism": 0.11764705882352941,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.058823529411764705,
"materials_and_methods": 0.6470588235294118,
"praise": 0.23529411764705882,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.17647058823529413,
"results_and_discussion": 0.058823529411764705,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.... | 1.647059 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control\nStudy\nVersion: 0 Date: 09 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe manuscript is updated and readable, and the authors have well reported and... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02780-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control
Study
Version: 0 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors, please address the following points below
-While the manuscript defines operational and prope tolerance, more clarity could be ... | Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control
Study
Version: 0 Date: 11 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors, please address the following points below
-While the manuscript defines operational and prope tolerance, more clarity could be ... | BMC | 12893_2025_2780_ReviewerReport_V0_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 16,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 3,
"results_and_discussion": 6,
"suggestion_and_solution": 13,
"total": 20
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.1,
"materials_and_methods": 0.8,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.15,
"results_and_discussion": 0.3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.65
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control\nStudy\nVersion: 0 Date: 11 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr\nReviewer's report:\nDear Authors, please address the following... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02780-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control
Study
Version: 1 Date: 17 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
changes are satisfactory, can be accepted for publication. | Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control
Study
Version: 1 Date: 17 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
changes are satisfactory, can be accepted for publication. | BMC | 12893_2025_2780_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control\nStudy\nVersion: 1 Date: 17 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr\nReviewer's report:\nchanges are satisfactory, can be accepted ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02780-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control
Study
Version: 1 Date: 02 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript is well-written and easy to understand. A statistical method would be acceptable.
Moreover, round 1 revision was performed point-by-point, and I believe that thi... | Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control
Study
Version: 1 Date: 02 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The manuscript is well-written and easy to understand. A statistical method would be acceptable.
Moreover, round 1 revision was performed point-by-point, and I believe that thi... | BMC | 12893_2025_2780_ReviewerReport_V1_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 4,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 5,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 9,
"total": 14
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.07142857142857142,
"materials_and_methods": 0.2857142857142857,
"praise": 0.07142857142857142,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.35714285714285715,
"results_and_discussion": 0.14285714285714285,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.6428571428571429
} | 1.571429 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control\nStudy\nVersion: 1 Date: 02 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe manuscript is well-written and easy to understand. A statistical method wo... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02780-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control
Study
Version: 2 Date: 07 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors clarified some questions in detail. The revised manuscript will be satisfactory for
publication. | Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control
Study
Version: 2 Date: 07 Jan 2025
Reviewer's report:
The authors clarified some questions in detail. The revised manuscript will be satisfactory for
publication. | BMC | 12893_2025_2780_ReviewerReport_V2_R5.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Allograft Tolerance after Adult Living Donor Liver Transplantation: A Case-Control\nStudy\nVersion: 2 Date: 07 Jan 2025\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors clarified some questions in detail. The revised manuscript will be... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02740-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 3 Date: 17 Jul 2024
Reviewer: Cenk Mustafa Guven
Reviewer's report: | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 3 Date: 17 Jul 2024
Reviewer: Cenk Mustafa Guven
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12893_2024_2740_ReviewerReport_V3_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal\nendoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study\nVersion: 3 Date: 17 Jul 2024\nReviewer: Cenk Musta... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02740-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 3 Date: 26 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
The study is well designed however authors should state the study limitations and strength
To enhan... | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 3 Date: 26 Aug 2024
Reviewer's report:
The study is well designed however authors should state the study limitations and strength
To enhan... | BMC | 12893_2024_2740_ReviewerReport_V3_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 4 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal\nendoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study\nVersion: 3 Date: 26 Aug 2024\nReviewer's report:\nT... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02740-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 4 Date: 24 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Cenk Mustafa Guven
Reviewer's report:
After the revisions, the study has become more clear an poweful in th... | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 4 Date: 24 Oct 2024
Reviewer: Cenk Mustafa Guven
Reviewer's report:
After the revisions, the study has become more clear an poweful in th... | BMC | 12893_2024_2740_ReviewerReport_V4_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal\nendoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study\nVersion: 4 Date: 24 Oct 2024\nReviewer: Cenk Musta... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02740-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 4 Date: 09 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
The recent sharp increase in ectopic pregnancies is related to the sharp increase in ART. Many
pati... | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 4 Date: 09 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report:
The recent sharp increase in ectopic pregnancies is related to the sharp increase in ART. Many
pati... | BMC | 12893_2024_2740_ReviewerReport_V4_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 3
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3333333333333333,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 0.333333 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal\nendoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study\nVersion: 4 Date: 09 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:\nT... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02740-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 5 Date: 15 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Cenk Mustafa Guven
Reviewer's report:
The revised form of the study can be accepted for publication | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 5 Date: 15 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Cenk Mustafa Guven
Reviewer's report:
The revised form of the study can be accepted for publication | BMC | 12893_2024_2740_ReviewerReport_V5_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 3 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal\nendoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study\nVersion: 5 Date: 15 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Cenk Musta... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02740-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 5 Date: 15 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The paper is well revised no further comments | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 5 Date: 15 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The paper is well revised no further comments | BMC | 12893_2024_2740_ReviewerReport_V5_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal\nendoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study\nVersion: 5 Date: 15 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nT... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02740-5 | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 5 Date: 22 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
You have done a good job of revising your manuscript to address the reviewers' points. | Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal
endoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study
Version: 5 Date: 22 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
You have done a good job of revising your manuscript to address the reviewers' points. | BMC | 12893_2024_2740_ReviewerReport_V5_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1
} | 3 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Analysis of feasibility, effectiveness and safety of transvaginal natural orifice transluminal\nendoscopic surgery(vNOTES) of ectopic pregnancy: a retrospective study\nVersion: 5 Date: 22 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nY... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02757-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients
undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis
Version: 1 Date: 24 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report: | Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients
undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis
Version: 1 Date: 24 Nov 2024
Reviewer's report: | BMC | 12893_2024_2757_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 1
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients\nundergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis\nVersion: 1 Date: 24 Nov 2024\nReviewer's report:",
"role": "assistant"
... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02757-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients
undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis
Version: 1 Date: 02 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to revise your manuscript. It was very interesting, and I wish you
all the best in your future... | Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients
undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis
Version: 1 Date: 02 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
Thank you for the opportunity to revise your manuscript. It was very interesting, and I wish you
all the best in your future... | BMC | 12893_2024_2757_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.5,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0.5,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 2 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients\nundergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis\nVersion: 1 Date: 02 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThank you for the opportun... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02757-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients
undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis
Version: 1 Date: 03 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors, please address the following points below
-The formula for calculating the ... | Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients
undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis
Version: 1 Date: 03 Dec 2024
Reviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr
Reviewer's report:
Dear Authors, please address the following points below
-The formula for calculating the ... | BMC | 12893_2024_2757_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 3,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 12,
"praise": 3,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 8,
"suggestion_and_solution": 10,
"total": 16
} | {
"criticism": 0.1875,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.125,
"materials_and_methods": 0.75,
"praise": 0.1875,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.125,
"results_and_discussion": 0.5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.625
} | 2.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients\nundergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis\nVersion: 1 Date: 03 Dec 2024\nReviewer: Anwar Ashraf Abouelnasr\nReviewer's... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02757-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients
undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis
Version: 2 Date: 09 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
As mentioned in the conclusion section, a lower PNI is a predictor of worse survival. Can you
provide a specific numerical P... | Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients
undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis
Version: 2 Date: 09 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
As mentioned in the conclusion section, a lower PNI is a predictor of worse survival. Can you
provide a specific numerical P... | BMC | 12893_2024_2757_ReviewerReport_V2_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.5,
"results_and_discussion": 0.5,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 2.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients\nundergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis\nVersion: 2 Date: 09 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nAs mentioned in the conclu... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02757-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients
undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis
Version: 2 Date: 16 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
I am honored to have the opportunity to revise the manuscript. It was of great interest, and I
wish you all the best for you... | Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients
undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis
Version: 2 Date: 16 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
I am honored to have the opportunity to revise the manuscript. It was of great interest, and I
wish you all the best for you... | BMC | 12893_2024_2757_ReviewerReport_V2_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.5,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.5
} | 2.5 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients\nundergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis\nVersion: 2 Date: 16 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nI am honored to have the o... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-024-02757-w | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients
undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis
Version: 3 Date: 23 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors have revised the points that I have previously suggested. There were no further
comments on this topic. | Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients
undergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis
Version: 3 Date: 23 Dec 2024
Reviewer's report:
The authors have revised the points that I have previously suggested. There were no further
comments on this topic. | BMC | 12893_2024_2757_ReviewerReport_V3_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 1,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 1,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0,
"total": 2
} | {
"criticism": 0.5,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0,
"results_and_discussion": 0,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0
} | 1 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Predictive role of the prognostic nutritional index for long-term prognosis among patients\nundergoing pancreatoduodenectomy: A meta-analysis\nVersion: 3 Date: 23 Dec 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe authors have revised t... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02778-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular
Carcinoma: A comprehensive review
Version: 1 Date: 07 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is a clinical review of the HCC treatment with radiofrequency ablation and immunotherapy.
The article focused on the beneficial effects of combination... | Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular
Carcinoma: A comprehensive review
Version: 1 Date: 07 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is a clinical review of the HCC treatment with radiofrequency ablation and immunotherapy.
The article focused on the beneficial effects of combination... | BMC | 12893_2025_2778_ReviewerReport_V1_R3.pdf | {
"criticism": 5,
"example": 7,
"importance_and_relevance": 1,
"materials_and_methods": 5,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 13,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 13,
"total": 33
} | {
"criticism": 0.15151515151515152,
"example": 0.21212121212121213,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.030303030303030304,
"materials_and_methods": 0.15151515151515152,
"praise": 0.030303030303030304,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.3939393939393939,
"results_and_discussion": 0.06060606060606061,
"suggestion... | 1.424242 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular\nCarcinoma: A comprehensive review\nVersion: 1 Date: 07 Apr 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis is a clinical review of the HCC treatment with radio... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02778-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular
Carcinoma: A comprehensive review
Version: 1 Date: 09 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is a comprehensive and detail review of RFA and immunotherapy of HCC treatment,
especially in the aspect of molecular mechanism. However, I still have... | Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular
Carcinoma: A comprehensive review
Version: 1 Date: 09 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
This is a comprehensive and detail review of RFA and immunotherapy of HCC treatment,
especially in the aspect of molecular mechanism. However, I still have... | BMC | 12893_2025_2778_ReviewerReport_V1_R4.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 2,
"materials_and_methods": 12,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 1,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 13
} | {
"criticism": 0.15384615384615385,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0.15384615384615385,
"materials_and_methods": 0.9230769230769231,
"praise": 0.07692307692307693,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.07692307692307693,
"results_and_discussion": 0.07692307692307693,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.23... | 1.692308 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular\nCarcinoma: A comprehensive review\nVersion: 1 Date: 09 Apr 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThis is a comprehensive and detail review of RFA and immu... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02778-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular
Carcinoma: A comprehensive review
Version: 1 Date: 11 Apr 2024
Reviewer: Kevin M. Sullivan
Reviewer's report:
In this manuscript, Xie et al describe the immunosuppressive tumor immune microenvironment
of the liver and HCC, and the ratio... | Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular
Carcinoma: A comprehensive review
Version: 1 Date: 11 Apr 2024
Reviewer: Kevin M. Sullivan
Reviewer's report:
In this manuscript, Xie et al describe the immunosuppressive tumor immune microenvironment
of the liver and HCC, and the ratio... | BMC | 12893_2025_2778_ReviewerReport_V1_R1.pdf | {
"criticism": 10,
"example": 3,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 9,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 11,
"results_and_discussion": 3,
"suggestion_and_solution": 11,
"total": 30
} | {
"criticism": 0.3333333333333333,
"example": 0.1,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.3,
"praise": 0,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.36666666666666664,
"results_and_discussion": 0.1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.36666666666666664
} | 1.566667 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular\nCarcinoma: A comprehensive review\nVersion: 1 Date: 11 Apr 2024\nReviewer: Kevin M. Sullivan\nReviewer's report:\nIn this manuscript, Xie et ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02778-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular
Carcinoma: A comprehensive review
Version: 1 Date: 14 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
It’s a completed and detailed review about the influence on the TME of HCC from RFA.
Studies on the relationship of immunology therapy and RFA in recent ye... | Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular
Carcinoma: A comprehensive review
Version: 1 Date: 14 Apr 2024
Reviewer's report:
It’s a completed and detailed review about the influence on the TME of HCC from RFA.
Studies on the relationship of immunology therapy and RFA in recent ye... | BMC | 12893_2025_2778_ReviewerReport_V1_R2.pdf | {
"criticism": 2,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 2,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 3,
"total": 11
} | {
"criticism": 0.18181818181818182,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5454545454545454,
"praise": 0.18181818181818182,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.18181818181818182,
"results_and_discussion": 0.09090909090909091,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.2727272727272727
} | 1.454545 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular\nCarcinoma: A comprehensive review\nVersion: 1 Date: 14 Apr 2024\nReviewer's report:\nIt’s a completed and detailed review about the influence ... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02778-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular
Carcinoma: A comprehensive review
Version: 2 Date: 11 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
The author revised the manuscript thoroughly and it is much better than before. But some
responses are inappropriate.
1. The response of Reviewer 1 Comment... | Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular
Carcinoma: A comprehensive review
Version: 2 Date: 11 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
The author revised the manuscript thoroughly and it is much better than before. But some
responses are inappropriate.
1. The response of Reviewer 1 Comment... | BMC | 12893_2025_2778_ReviewerReport_V2_R8.pdf | {
"criticism": 4,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 2,
"praise": 2,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 2,
"suggestion_and_solution": 5,
"total": 16
} | {
"criticism": 0.25,
"example": 0,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.125,
"praise": 0.125,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.25,
"results_and_discussion": 0.125,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.3125
} | 1.1875 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular\nCarcinoma: A comprehensive review\nVersion: 2 Date: 11 Jul 2024\nReviewer's report:\nThe author revised the manuscript thoroughly and it is mu... | 2,025 | ||
0 | 0 | Review for 10.1186/s12893-025-02778-z | Reviewed - bmc_surgery | Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular
Carcinoma: A comprehensive review
Version: 2 Date: 15 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
Overall much of the English language editing is improved, but the new content of the abstract
remains hard to follow from a comprehension perspective.
The ... | Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular
Carcinoma: A comprehensive review
Version: 2 Date: 15 Jul 2024
Reviewer's report:
Overall much of the English language editing is improved, but the new content of the abstract
remains hard to follow from a comprehension perspective.
The ... | BMC | 12893_2025_2778_ReviewerReport_V2_R7.pdf | {
"criticism": 4,
"example": 4,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 6,
"praise": 1,
"presentation_and_reporting": 4,
"results_and_discussion": 1,
"suggestion_and_solution": 1,
"total": 11
} | {
"criticism": 0.36363636363636365,
"example": 0.36363636363636365,
"importance_and_relevance": 0,
"materials_and_methods": 0.5454545454545454,
"praise": 0.09090909090909091,
"presentation_and_reporting": 0.36363636363636365,
"results_and_discussion": 0.09090909090909091,
"suggestion_and_solution": 0.09... | 1.909091 | 0 | [
{
"content": "Please review this paper.",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "Title: Radiofrequency Ablation Combined with Immunotherapy to Treat Hepatocellular\nCarcinoma: A comprehensive review\nVersion: 2 Date: 15 Jul 2024\nReviewer's report:\nOverall much of the English language editing is improved,... | 2,025 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.